Co-authored by Matthew Greenhill
It has been eight months since the Independent Football Regulator (IFR) published a series of consultations covering topics including sanctions, information gathering and enforcement, and a proposed Owners, Directors and Senior Executives regime. Regulation by the IFR, established pursuant to the Football Governance Act 2025 (FGA 2025) and with powers taking effect from 1 November 2025, represents a significant change in the way English professional clubs are governed. One of its most recent consultations, published in January this year, is the Terms of Reference for its State of the Game report (SoG report), a wide-ranging review with a primary focus on men’s football, but which the IFR hopes will have broader significance for the industry as a whole. With the consultation having closed in February 2026, we consider the scope of the report and how its impact may shape the governance arrangements, licensing and funding of in-scope football clubs for years to come.
Background to the SoG report
The IFR was established by the UK government to a background of governance failings in English football, including an attempted breakaway of six English clubs to join a European Super League and the high-profile financial collapse of certain football clubs.
The IFR’s objectives are to:
- Protect and promote the financial soundness of regulated football clubs;
- Protect and promote financial resilience of English football clubs; and
- Safeguard the heritage of English football.
You can read more on the background to the FGA 2025, or learn more about the wider regulatory developments.
As part of efforts to encourage a culture of openness and transparency in the English football industry, the IFR, pursuant to Section 10(1) of the FGA 2025, is required to publish a SoG report as soon as reasonably practicable, and in any case no later than 18 months after it became operational (Section 10(3) FGA 2025).
In a 11 June 2025 fact sheet on the then Football Governance Bill, the UK government stated that the report will include, at a minimum, “an overview of the main issues that the IFR considers to be affecting English football, and an assessment of whether any features of the market threaten the IFR’s ability to advance its objectives”.
In January 2026, the IFR published its consultation on the first SoG report, with the consultation closing on 17 February 2026. We examine some of the proposed topics to be covered by the SoG report below.
What will the first SoG report cover?
Broad issues that will be examined by the IFR include broadcast revenues, player wages, club ownership, financial distributions and academy development, to name just a few. And while the scope of the report covers only the top five English men’s leagues, the IFR suggests that the SoG report will be used to provide an insight into the “wider football ecosystem”, allowing it to “make an objective and evidence-based assessment” of underlying risk and issues and “inform the IFR’s overall regulatory approach”.
The IFR’s Terms of Reference set out a number of key themes to be addressed in the report, though the IFR is clear to stress that the list below is not a complete list of topics intended to be captured by the report. The IFR intends to do the following with the SoG report:
-
Assess the industry background, including, amongst other things, analysis of clubs’ incomes and costs, the market for players, the ownership of stadiums, the role of competition organisers and the wider regulatory and legal landscape.
-
Analyse the economics of the football industry, with main sub-themes including:
- Club Business Models: covering how clubs manage cost, revenues and financial risk;
- Liquidity: reviewing how clubs meet their short-term financial obligations (such as cash flow and working capital);
- Solvency: looking at how clubs meet their long-term debt obligations; and
- Governance: reviewing clubs’ internal structures and controls in order to mitigate financial risk.
-
Identify and assess the systemic resilience of football clubs, assessing, for example, the market for players, the broadcast market, the investor landscape and the industry’s resilience to macroeconomic shocks.
-
Undertake a wide-ranging investigation of revenue distribution, covering a variety of topics, including financial ‘cliff-edges’ faced by recently promoted clubs alongside reviewing the English Premier League’s practice of making parachute payments to recently regulated clubs. This area will also focus on the distribution of revenue to the “wider football ecosystem” including to women’s football and community and grassroot football clubs.
-
Assess fan engagement, to understand the challenges faced by clubs in their fan engagement models. This section will also address the important issues relating to club heritage.
-
Review clubs’ approaches to corporate governance, Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion (EDI) and community outreach, with a view to understanding the benefits of the existing approaches and the challenges that they are currently facing.
-
Identify and consider emerging opportunities and challenges in English football.
What can we expect for the future?
The IFR’s regulatory programme is well underway, with a number of consultations, rules and guidance expected to be implemented throughout the course of 2026. A draft of the SoG report is expected later in 2026, with the finalised report due for publication in 2027. The IFR will be required to publish a similar report every five years, starting from the date the first report is published.