In Process & Industrial Developments Ltd v The Federal Republic of Nigeria [2025] UKSC 36, the Supreme Court provided clear guidance on which currency should be used for costs awards. The Court upheld an order awarding Nigeria its costs in sterling, emphasising that a costs order is a discretionary contribution to a party’s liability incurred to its own lawyers, and not an indemnity designed to compensate a receiving party against loss akin to a damages award. The Court held that, as a general rule, costs should be ordered in sterling, or in the currency in which the receiving party was billed by and paid its lawyers.
Background
Nigeria brought Commercial Court proceedings to challenge an arbitration award on grounds of serious irregularity, which culminated in an eight-week trial. It incurred £44 million in legal fees which were invoiced and paid in sterling between 2019 and 2024. After Nigeria succeeded at trial, the Court awarded Nigeria its costs. Process & Industrial Developments Ltd (P&ID), the paying party, contended that the costs should be ordered in naira rather than sterling, as Nigeria had paid its legal fees by converting naira into sterling. It argued that depreciation in the value of the naira meant an award in sterling would confer a windfall on Nigeria and that the Court should choose the currency that most accurately reflected the receiving party’s “loss” in funding litigation. Both the Commercial Court and the Court of Appeal rejected that approach and ordered that the costs award should be in sterling.
P&ID appealed, urging the Supreme Court to adopt a principle drawn from damages cases, and select the currency which best reflected the claimant’s loss.
The Supreme Court’s decision
The Supreme Court rejected the appeal.
Costs are not damages
The Supreme Court’s starting point was that an order for costs is different from an award of damages which seeks to compensate for loss. Under the Senior Courts Act 1981 and CPR Part 44, costs are a discretionary contribution to expenditure incurred in litigation. A court’s task in making a costs award is to identify the reasonable amount that the paying party should pay as a contribution to the receiving party’s costs. The “indemnity principle” prevents recovery of costs beyond the party’s liability to its lawyers, but it does not convert a costs award into a loss‑based award. This distinction matters when considering the appropriate currency. The line of authorities on foreign‑currency damages awards asks which currency best values the claimant’s loss. However, the Court confirmed that this analysis does not apply to costs.
Avoiding satellite disputes about funding and foreign exchange rates
A central concern of the Supreme Court was the risk of collateral disputes if courts were required to investigate how a party obtained the money to pay its lawyers, whether by converting domestic currency, drawing on foreign‑currency reserves, selling assets or obtaining third‑party finance. The Court saw these inquiries as contrary to the overriding objective of dealing with cases justly and at proportionate cost. Further, in this case, an order in naira would have required the application of 116 different historic exchange rates across a bill of costs running to 95,429 items, which the Court deemed to be plainly a disproportionate exercise. The Court stated that it should be “very slow” to adopt any approach likely to generate expensive satellite litigation.
A general rule: Sterling or the billing currency
The Supreme Court held that there should be a general rule for determining the appropriate currency: an order for costs should be in sterling or in the currency in which the solicitor had billed and the client had paid (or was liable to pay). Such a rule was consistent with the nature of the court’s costs jurisdiction and with legal certainty. In ordinary cases, particularly where English solicitors and counsel have conducted the litigation and billed in sterling, costs should therefore be awarded in sterling.
Possible exceptions
The Court left room for exceptions to the general rule, noting that there may be circumstances in which a court chooses not to award costs in the currency in which the receiving party paid its lawyers. This includes where the parties’ choice of currency was abusive or inappropriate – for example, where a litigant with no real connection to a particular currency chose it to speculate on foreign exchange movements. In such as case, the court could properly make the costs award in sterling. The Court noted that, if a practice developed by which litigants in England and Wales paid their lawyers and sought recovery of costs in currencies other than sterling, it might be necessary to develop court rules to ensure that parties were aware that was occurring. This would safeguard the court’s ability to control costs and protect the paying party from currency fluctuations.
Key takeaways
The Supreme Court’s decision answers a narrow but important question on the appropriate currency for costs. It reaffirms the distinctive character of a costs order, supplies a clear default rule for costs awards, and discourages unproductive disputes about sources of funding and foreign exchange rates. For most cases, the question of which currency should be used in a costs award will have a straightforward answer: sterling or the currency in which the solicitor has billed the client and in which the client has paid.
The judgment also fits with the broader trend towards costs management and proportionality. By awarding costs in line with the billing currency, the Court avoids the risk of undermining budgeting processes and allows parties to price risk with greater confidence as cases progress.
With thanks to Tara Cavan for their assistance in preparing this post.